Doctrine & Covenants 104

The Reorganization of the United Order
April 23, 1834 • Kirtland, Ohio

Section Overview

Basic Information

Date of Revelation: April 23, 1834

Location: Kirtland, Ohio

Recipients: Joseph Smith and members of the United Order

Verses: 86 verses

Section Summary: The Lord reorganizes the United Order following covenant breaking by some members, establishes individual stewardships while maintaining collective consecration principles, and provides detailed instructions for managing Church properties and debts during a critical financial crisis.

Key Principles

Primary Doctrinal Principle: True consecration operates through individual stewardships within a collective covenant, where each person is accountable to God for their portion while contributing to the common good.

Secondary Principle: Breaking covenants through covetousness brings severe spiritual consequences, including being delivered to the buffetings of Satan until redemption.

Application Principle: The Lord's way of caring for the poor requires the rich to be made low through consecration, creating equality and abundance for all.

Timeframe & Setting

Circumstances Among Recipients

The United Order members faced a severe financial crisis. Some had broken their consecration covenants through covetousness and "feigned words" (v. 4). The order owed substantial debts, particularly for the temple lot and other properties. Members struggled between individual needs and collective obligations. Trust had been damaged by those who failed to live the law fully.

Circumstances Within the Church

The Church was preparing for Zion's Camp (D&C 103 given February 24, 1834). Temple construction in Kirtland required significant resources. The Missouri Saints had been driven from Jackson County and needed assistance. The original United Order structure proved unworkable due to human weakness and geographical separation between Ohio and Missouri.

Relevant Local Circumstances

Kirtland's economy was strained by the influx of Saints. Local merchants extended credit but expected payment. Anti-Mormon sentiment affected business dealings. The frontier economy operated largely on credit and promissory notes. Legal pressures mounted as creditors sought payment for Church debts.

Relevant Global Circumstances

Andrew Jackson's presidency saw economic volatility and the Bank War. The American frontier expansion created both opportunities and instabilities. Communitarian experiments like the Shakers provided alternative economic models. The concept of corporate ownership was still developing in American law.

Purpose of the Revelation

Short Term

Dissolve the original United Order structure that had failed; assign specific stewardships to individual members; address immediate debt crisis threatening Church properties; separate Kirtland and Missouri operations; provide clear accountability for temporal resources.

Long Term

Establish eternal principles of consecration and stewardship; create a pattern for future economic cooperation; teach the relationship between temporal and spiritual salvation; prepare the Church for greater collective efforts; establish the law of tithing's foundation (later given in D&C 119).

Significance

Short Term

The revelation saved Church properties from creditors. Members received individual stewardships providing personal responsibility. The separation of Kirtland and Missouri orders prevented total financial collapse. Specific assignments clarified roles and responsibilities. The debt management plan provided hope for financial freedom.

Long Term

This revelation established principles still governing Church welfare and finances. The concept of stewardship over consecration shapes modern Church programs. Individual accountability within collective goals remains central to Church organization. The promise of deliverance from debt through faithfulness continues to bless Saints. The pattern of temporal self-reliance supporting spiritual purposes endures.

Cultural Insights

Ancient

The concept of Jubilee years and debt forgiveness echoes throughout (Leviticus 25). Individual stewardships mirror the tribal inheritances of Israel (Numbers 26:52-56). The treasury system parallels the temple treasury of ancient times (Mark 12:41-44). Covenant curses for unfaithfulness reflect Deuteronomic patterns (Deuteronomy 28). The principle of gleaning fields for the poor is expanded (Leviticus 19:9-10).

Modern

The revelation addresses modern economic challenges of debt and wealth inequality. Corporate structures and individual accountability within organizations reflect these principles. The welfare system of the Church implements these consecration principles. Modern stake and ward councils operate on similar organizational patterns. The principle of "enough and to spare" (v. 17) counters scarcity mindset.

Modern Application

  • Personal Application: Recognize all possessions as stewardships from God; practice generous fast offerings and tithing; eliminate unnecessary debt; share abundance with those in need
  • Family Application: Teach children about stewardship vs. ownership; implement family councils for financial decisions; practice consecration through family service; establish family emergency funds
  • Church Application: Support ward welfare efforts; magnify callings as stewardships; contribute to temple building; participate in self-reliance programs
  • Community Application: Ethical business practices reflecting consecration; community service using professional skills; economic justice advocacy; sustainable resource management
  • Questions for Personal Study: How can I better recognize my stewardships? What would true consecration look like in my life? How do I balance individual needs with collective good? What debts (spiritual or temporal) need addressing? How can I prepare for future consecration requirements?

Key Doctrines

  • Stewardship Accountability: Every person must give an account of their stewardship to God
  • Divine Ownership: "All things are mine" (v. 14) - God owns earth and everything in it
  • Consecration Law: The rich made low and poor exalted creating equality
  • Agency in Temporalities: Men are agents unto themselves in managing earthly resources
  • Covenant Consequences: Breaking sacred covenants brings temporal and spiritual cursing
  • Collective Salvation: Individual salvation connected to community welfare
  • Debt and Deliverance: Spiritual pattern of bondage and redemption through faithfulness

Historical Context

The Financial Crisis of 1834

Immediate Debts

  • Temple Lot: $2,000 owed for Kirtland Temple land
  • Printing Office: Debts for press and supplies
  • Personal Debts: Leaders had pledged personal credit
  • Missouri Aid: Supporting expelled Saints required funds

Failed Business Ventures

  • Tannery: Sidney Rigdon's operation struggled
  • Store: N.K. Whitney's mercantile faced credit issues
  • Farm Operations: Poor yields and market prices
  • United Order Store: Competition with non-member merchants

Why the Original Order Failed

Human Weaknesses

Covetousness among some members created discord. Unequal sacrifice perception led to resentment. Geographic separation between Ohio and Missouri made coordination difficult. Lack of business experience hindered operations. External persecution pressure stressed the system.

Structural Issues

No clear individual accountability existed in the original structure. Unclear property rights created confusion. Mixed spiritual and temporal authority complicated decisions. Insufficient capital base limited operations. Legal vulnerability exposed the order to external threats.

The Reorganization Solution

Individual Stewardships

Clear property assignments gave each member specific responsibility. Personal accountability was established through individual stewardships. Inheritance rights were defined for posterity. Business name separation protected assets legally.

Maintained Unity

Common treasury for publishing preserved collective efforts. Committee governance provided checks and balances. Mutual support obligations continued among members. Shared spiritual purposes unified the separated orders.

Key People and Their Assignments

  • Sidney Rigdon: Received the tannery lot for his stewardship
  • Martin Harris: Assigned land to devote money for proclaiming the word
  • Frederick G. Williams: Kept his residence and shared printing office
  • Oliver Cowdery: Received printing office lot with Williams
  • John Johnson: Kept his house and managed lot sales
  • Newel K. Whitney: Appointed over mercantile establishment as treasurer
  • Joseph Smith Jr.: Received temple lot and inheritance for father's support

Connection to Other Revelations

  • D&C 42:30-42 - Original law of consecration
  • D&C 78 - Establishment of the United Order
  • D&C 82 - Binding nature of the order
  • D&C 103 - Zion's Camp preparation context
  • D&C 105 - Later evaluation of united efforts

Long-Term Impact

Immediate Results

Properties were saved from creditors through the reorganization. Publishing of revelations continued uninterrupted. Members had clear roles and responsibilities. Missouri and Ohio operations were successfully separated.

Future Patterns Established

The pattern of bishops' storehouses emerged from these principles. Ward welfare systems follow the consecration model. The Church welfare program implements these concepts globally. Humanitarian efforts reflect the abundance principle. The Perpetual Education Fund embodies stewardship accountability.

Verse-by-Verse Study Guide

Scripture Text

1 Verily I say unto you, my friends, I give unto you counsel, and a commandment, concerning all the properties which belong to the order which I commanded to be organized and established, to be a united order, and an everlasting order for the benefit of my church, and for the salvation of men until I come—

2 With promise immutable and unchangeable, that inasmuch as those whom I commanded were faithful they should be blessed with a multiplicity of blessings;

3 But inasmuch as they were not faithful they were nigh unto cursing.

4 Therefore, inasmuch as some of my servants have not kept the commandment, but have broken the covenant through covetousness, and with feigned words, I have cursed them with a very sore and grievous curse.

5 For I, the Lord, have decreed in my heart, that inasmuch as any man belonging to the order shall be found a transgressor, or, in other words, shall break the covenant with which ye are bound, he shall be cursed in his life, and shall be trodden down by whom I will;

6 For I, the Lord, am not to be mocked in these things—

7 And all this that the innocent among you may not be condemned with the unjust; and that the guilty among you may not escape; because I, the Lord, have promised unto you a crown of glory at my right hand.

8 Therefore, inasmuch as you are found transgressors, you cannot escape my wrath in your lives.

9 Inasmuch as ye are cut off for transgression, ye cannot escape the buffetings of Satan until the day of redemption.

10 And I now give unto you power from this very hour, that if any man among you, of the order, is found a transgressor and repenteth not of the evil, that ye shall deliver him over unto the buffetings of Satan; and he shall not have power to bring evil upon you.

Doctrinal Summary Points

  • The United Order was established as an everlasting principle for salvation
  • Faithfulness brings multiplicity of blessings; unfaithfulness brings cursing
  • Covetousness and deception ("feigned words") broke the covenant
  • God will not be mocked in sacred covenants
  • Church discipline includes delivering unrepentant to Satan's buffetings

Language & Cultural Insights

  • "feigned words" - Hebrew: כָּזָב (*kazab*) — "lies, deception, falsehood"
  • "buffetings of Satan" - Greek: κολαφίζω (*kolaphizo*) — "to strike with fist, buffet, maltreat"
  • "immutable and unchangeable" - Legal language emphasizing eternal nature of divine promises
  • "trodden down" - Ancient Near Eastern imagery of conquest and judgment

Cross-References

Modern Application

Understanding the seriousness of covenant keeping helps us approach our temple covenants with appropriate reverence. The principle of church discipline protecting the innocent while offering redemption to the guilty guides modern councils of love.

Scripture Text

11 It is wisdom in me; therefore, a commandment I give unto you, that ye shall organize yourselves and appoint every man his stewardship;

12 That every man may give an account unto me of the stewardship which is appointed unto him.

13 For it is expedient that I, the Lord, should make every man accountable, as a steward over earthly blessings, which I have made and prepared for my creatures.

14 I, the Lord, stretched out the heavens, and built the earth, my very handiwork; and all things therein are mine.

15 And it is my purpose to provide for my saints, for all things are mine.

16 But it must needs be done in mine own way; and behold this is the way that I, the Lord, have decreed to provide for my saints, that the poor shall be exalted, in that the rich are made low.

17 For the earth is full, and there is enough and to spare; yea, I prepared all things, and have given unto the children of men to be agents unto themselves.

18 Therefore, if any man shall take of the abundance which I have made, and impart not his portion, according to the law of my gospel, unto the poor and the needy, he shall, with the wicked, lift up his eyes in hell, being in torment.

Doctrinal Summary Points

  • Individual stewardships within collective consecration
  • Accountability to God for temporal resources
  • Divine ownership of all creation
  • God's way reverses worldly economic patterns
  • Earth has abundance for all if shared properly
  • Agency in temporal matters carries eternal consequences

Language & Cultural Insights

  • "stewardship" - Greek: οἰκονομία (*oikonomia*) — "management of household affairs"
  • "enough and to spare" - Contradicts scarcity economics
  • "agents unto themselves" - Unique LDS doctrine of moral agency in temporalities
  • "lift up his eyes in hell" - Reference to rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:23)

Cross-References

Modern Application

Recognizing God's ownership changes how we view possessions—we are managers, not owners. The principle of "enough and to spare" counters modern scarcity mindset and hoarding behaviors. Our use of abundance determines our eternal state.

Scripture Text

19-26 [The Lord assigns specific properties to Sidney Rigdon (tannery lot), Martin Harris (land for proclaiming the word), and instructs Martin to devote money according to Joseph Smith's direction]

27-33 [Frederick G. Williams keeps his residence and shares the printing office with Oliver Cowdery; both receive stewardship over publishing]

34-38 [John Johnson receives his house and manages lot sales for building up the city]

39-42 [Newel K. Whitney appointed over the mercantile establishment as a stewardship for the order's business]

43-46 [Joseph Smith Jr. receives the temple lot and inheritance for his father's support]

Doctrinal Summary Points

  • Specific properties assigned to individual leaders
  • Stewardships include provision for "seed after him" (posterity)
  • Printing office given to Williams and Cowdery for publishing revelations
  • Whitney's mercantile establishment serves the order's business needs
  • Joseph Smith receives property for temple building and family support

Language & Cultural Insights

  • "tannery" - Leather processing facility, important frontier industry
  • "ashery" - Facility for producing potash from wood ashes, used in soap and glass making
  • "mercantile establishment" - General store serving as economic hub
  • "forty rods long and twelve wide" - Approximately 10 acres (1 rod = 16.5 feet)

Modern Application

The principle of specific stewardships continues in Church callings—each person has a defined responsibility. Support for aged parents (Joseph Smith Sr.) models family responsibility. Business enterprises can serve kingdom purposes when consecrated.

Scripture Text

47-53 [The Kirtland and Missouri orders are separated for practical necessity; each to operate independently but maintain the same principles]

54-62 [Treasury established for publishing; committee appointed to manage affairs; warnings about eternal life]

63-77 [Truth, light, and Spirit interconnected; the world lies in bondage of sin; God's word is certain and unchangeable]

Key Points from These Verses

  • Separation of Kirtland and Missouri orders for mutual salvation
  • Publishing revelations takes priority for treasury funds
  • "Live by every word that proceedeth forth from the mouth of God" (v. 63)
  • "Truth is light, and light is Spirit" (v. 64)
  • The world groans under bondage of sin without revelation
  • God's word will be fulfilled whether by His voice or His servants

Modern Application

Sometimes organizational changes are necessary for survival and growth. Publishing truth remains essential to the Church's mission. The interconnection of truth, light, and Spirit guides our search for knowledge.

Scripture Text

78 And again, verily I say unto you, concerning your debts—behold it is my will that you shall pay all your debts.

79 And it is my will that you shall humble yourselves before me, and obtain this blessing by your diligence and humility and the prayer of faith.

80 And inasmuch as you are diligent and humble, and exercise the prayer of faith, behold, I will soften the hearts of those to whom you are in debt, until I shall send means unto you for your deliverance.

81 Therefore write speedily to New York and write according to that which shall be dictated by my Spirit; and I will soften the hearts of those to whom you are in debt, that it shall be taken away out of their minds to bring affliction upon you.

82 And inasmuch as ye are humble and faithful and call upon my name, behold, I will give you the victory.

83 I give unto you a promise, that you shall be delivered this once out of your bondage.

84 Inasmuch as you obtain a chance to loan money by hundreds, or thousands, even until you shall loan enough to deliver yourself from bondage, it is your privilege.

85 And pledge the properties which I have put into your hands, this once, by giving your names by common consent or otherwise, as it shall seem good unto you.

86 I give unto you this privilege, this once; and behold, if you proceed to do the things which I have laid before you, according to my commandments, all these things are mine, and ye are my stewards, and the master will not suffer his house to be broken up. Even so. Amen.

Doctrinal Summary Points

  • Divine will requires paying all debts honorably
  • Deliverance comes through humility, diligence, and faith
  • The Lord can soften creditors' hearts
  • Permission to secure loans for debt consolidation
  • Properties can be pledged "this once" for deliverance
  • Warning against future debt accumulation

Cross-References

Modern Application

Debt elimination remains a priority for spiritual and temporal freedom. The Lord assists those who humbly work toward financial independence. Sometimes consolidation loans can provide relief, but should be used sparingly. Faith and practical action work together for deliverance.

Comprehensive Word Studies

1. Stewardship/Steward

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Etymology & Historical Usage

From Old English *stiweard*, literally "house guardian," from stig "hall, pen" + weard "guard"

Webster 1828: Stewardship — "The office of a steward; the management of domestic concerns"

Doctrinal Significance

In D&C 104, stewardship transforms from mere management to sacred accountability. Each person receives specific properties not as ownership but as divine trust, accountable to God for their use.

2. United Order

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

The United Order represents the temporal implementation of celestial law—unity in purpose while maintaining individual stewardships. It's not communism but consecration, requiring both collective commitment and personal accountability.

3. Covenant

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

In D&C 104, covenant breaking through "covetousness and feigned words" brings cursing. Sacred covenants with God involve both temporal and spiritual obligations, with severe consequences for violation.

4. Transgressor/Transgression

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

Transgression specifically refers to covenant breaking through covetousness. It results in being "cursed in life" and "trodden down," with ultimate delivery to Satan's buffetings.

5. Treasury

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

The treasury serves specific purposes—primarily publishing revelations and supporting Church leaders. It operates on "common consent," establishing the pattern for modern Church financial management.

6. Abundance

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

"The earth is full, and there is enough and to spare" (v. 17) contradicts worldly scarcity mindset. Abundance exists when shared according to God's law.

7. Buffetings of Satan

Hebrew Foundation

Greek Understanding

Doctrinal Significance

Being delivered to Satan's buffetings represents withdrawal of divine protection, allowing the adversary to afflict the transgressor. This continues "until the day of redemption," suggesting a long but not eternal duration.

Teaching Applications by Setting

Sunday School Application

Topic: "All Things Are Mine: Understanding Divine Ownership"

Opening Question: If God owns everything, what do we actually own?

Main Points:

  • Shift from ownership mentality to stewardship thinking
  • Everything we have is on loan from God
  • Accountability for how we use "our" resources
  • The abundance principle vs. scarcity mindset
  • How consecration differs from both communism and capitalism

Activity: Create a personal stewardship inventory—list possessions and how they serve God's purposes

Discussion Questions: How would your spending change if you saw yourself as God's financial manager? What's the difference between needs, wants, and abundance?

Seminary Application (Youth)

Topic: "Breaking Bad: The Danger of Covenant Breaking"

Key Concepts for Youth:

  • Covenants aren't just spiritual—they include temporal commitments
  • "Feigned words" (lying) in Church settings has serious consequences
  • Covetousness (wanting what others have) can break covenants
  • The buffetings of Satan are real and terrible
  • There's always a path back through repentance

Interactive Element: Case studies: "Is this covenant breaking?" Discuss modern examples of "feigned words"

Personal Challenge: Identify one area where you can be more honest in your discipleship

Institute Application (Young Adults)

Topic: "Economic Discipleship: Living Consecration Principles in Modern Capitalism"

Discussion Framework:

  • The Consecration Paradox: Individual stewardships in a collective system
  • Modern Applications: Tithing, fast offerings, career choices
  • Debt and Discipleship: When is debt acceptable?
  • Financial preparation for future consecration

Practical Exercises: Create a 5-year financial plan incorporating consecration principles; identify professional skills for kingdom building

Family Home Evening Application

For Younger Children: Tell about the early Saints sharing everything; use toys to show sharing vs. hoarding

For Teenagers: Discuss what our family would consecrate if asked; how does our family share abundance?

Family Activity: Create family stewardship assignments like D&C 104; each person identifies talents/resources for family/others

Parent Teaching Moment: Share how you've tried to live consecration in your life

Relief Society/Elders Quorum Application

Topic: "Temporal Self-Reliance and Collective Consecration"

Practical Discussion Points:

  • Ward-Level Consecration: How can we better share abundance in our ward?
  • Personal Finance and Consecration: Debt elimination as spiritual preparation
  • Modern United Orders: Ward welfare systems as mini-united orders
  • Skills and resources inventory for ward members

Action Items: Create ward skills database; establish debt elimination support groups; develop abundance sharing networks

Covenant Application: How do temple covenants relate to temporal consecration?

Study Questions for Personal and Family Study

Questions for Individual Reflection

1. What possessions do I struggle to see as God's rather than mine?

Consider: Which material things have the strongest hold on your identity or security?

2. Have I ever used "feigned words" in my discipleship? How can I be more authentic?

Consider: Times when you've pretended greater faith or commitment than you felt.

3. What debts (financial, emotional, spiritual) keep me in bondage?

Consider: The Lord promises deliverance "this once"—what needs addressing now?

4. How would I respond if asked to consecrate everything tomorrow?

Consider: What would be hardest to give up? What does that reveal about your heart?

5. What abundance do I have that I'm not sharing?

Consider: Time, talents, resources, knowledge—where is there "enough and to spare"?

Questions for Family Discussion

1. How can our family better recognize God's ownership of our possessions?

Discuss: Family prayers about stewardship, teaching children about tithing, family consecration projects.

2. What would our family's "stewardship assignments" be if we lived the United Order?

Discuss: Each person's unique contributions, talents, and responsibilities to the family.

3. How do we avoid covetousness in a materialistic world?

Discuss: Social media influences, peer pressure, advertising, keeping up with others.

4. What family debts need addressing for spiritual and temporal freedom?

Discuss: Financial planning, debt elimination strategies, living within means.

5. How can we teach children the principle of "enough and to spare"?

Discuss: Sharing toys, family service projects, generous fast offerings, helping neighbors.

Questions for Deeper Investigation

1. Research the people mentioned—what happened to their stewardships?

Study: Sidney Rigdon, Martin Harris, N.K. Whitney, Oliver Cowdery's later lives.

2. How did the Kirtland Safety Society (1837) relate to these economic principles?

Research: The banking crisis and its impact on consecration efforts.

3. What happened to Church finances after this reorganization?

Study: Development from United Order to tithing system (D&C 119).

4. How do modern Church welfare programs implement these principles?

Research: Bishops' storehouses, welfare farms, humanitarian efforts.

5. Study other religious communal economies—how did they compare?

Research: Shakers, Harmonists, Brook Farm, kibbutzim.

Questions for Practical Application

1. Create a personal financial plan based on D&C 104 principles—what changes?

Consider: Budgeting as stewardship, generous giving, debt elimination, building reserves to share.

2. Identify three ways to share your professional skills for kingdom building.

Consider: Pro bono work, Church service, mentoring, skills-based volunteering.

3. Develop a debt elimination strategy with specific timeline—when will you be free?

Consider: Snowball method, extra payments, lifestyle changes, increasing income.

4. List your "stewardships" and evaluate your management—where can you improve?

Consider: Time, talents, possessions, relationships, callings, opportunities.

5. Find someone in need and share from your abundance this week—who will it be?

Consider: Ward members, neighbors, community organizations, global humanitarian needs.

Cross-Reference Study Questions

Compare D&C 104:11-18 with Acts 4:32-37. How does the early Christian church's approach compare to the United Order?

Read Malachi 3:8-10. How does tithing relate to the consecration principles in D&C 104?

Study 4 Nephi 1:1-3. What allowed the Nephites to have "all things common" successfully?

Examine Luke 16:19-31 (Rich man and Lazarus). How does this parable relate to verse 18?

Consider D&C 119. How did the law of tithing replace the United Order? What principles remain?